How have estimates of the deaths in WWI and WWII changed over time?
Upvote:3
Estimates do change over time. There is a typical evolution to this modern-day conundrum:
Phase 1: The War is Still Ongoing
Almost always, opposing losses are over-stated and own losses are under-stated. Over-stating opposing losses is practically guaranteed, driven by battlefield confusion and a desire to prop up the home-front morale. Likewise, own losses may be not yet compiled and also under-stated (or not stated) due to "operational security," for both reasons of hiding weakness from the enemy and also propping up home-front morale.
Sometimes one or more sides can get carried away in over-stating their opponent's losses - it becomes a pandora's box that can't be easily shut after being opened, due to the political momentum.
Numbers published during this phase are also "anchors," in that any future adjustments or research has to relate to that initial anchor, no matter how far off that initial claim was.
Ukraine is currently in this stage. The numbers that have come out are not reliable and are incomplete, and neither side wants to be honest at this point because of operational security and home-front morale.
Phase 2: The War is Over, Rational Study Begins
Now historians take over. Initial claims get scrutiny as records are released. If a combatant had good record-keeping (and those records survived), these are researched and published. Statisticians may also give it a go with some math models, which can be refined with more inputs and correlation to known records. It can also be a matter of counting graves.
Some Examples
One easy-to-study example is the Axis surrender in Tunisia in May of 1943, and specifically how many Axis prisoners were taken. Liddell Hart [1] compiled these numbers from different sources:
- A report from General Alexander to General Eisenhower's HQ on May 12 claimed 100,000 prisoners, expected to rise to 130,000.
- A follow-up report from Alexander to Eisenhower claimed 150,000.
- Alexander published a despatch after the war that claimed 250,000.
- Churchill, in his memoirs, claimed "nearly a quarter million."
- Eisenhower later claimed 240,000, of which 125,000 were German.
- A report from Army Group Afrika to Rome on May 2 reported a ration strength of between 170,000-180,000 troops.
Liddell Hart tended to believe the logistics reports the most. The admin staff is likely the most aware and honest about the number of mouths they are feeding and have the least incentive to over-state or under-state those numbers. Liddell Hart goes on:
Here it is worth remark that much larger discrepancies still, between the last known German ration strength and the Allied claims about the number of prisoners captured, were manifest in the final stages of the war.
This kind of data is likely only to be found by researchers after the war, who are seeking these records and that those records can still be found.
Sometimes records that come to light later on can spark a controversy as well, if they disagree significantly with the existing narratives.
Another example is the controversial book, John Mosier's The Myth of the Great War [2]. The thesis of that book was to deduce what was really happening on the First World War battlefields, when records from the German side are used to correct the greatly inflated British claims of German losses.
[1] History of the Second World War. B.H. Liddell Hart, c 1970.
[2] The Myth of the Great War. John Mosier, c 2001.
More post
- 📝 Why did the Chinese Nationalist party members go to the island of Taiwan and not to any other island?
- 📝 What toilet facilities were available at large formal gatherings in 19th century America?
- 📝 Why were there so many Japanese Prime Ministers before and during WW2?
- 📝 When was the last promotion in the British Peerage?
- 📝 How did people put down a drinking horn?
- 📝 Has any music act ever topped the Beatles in sales?
- 📝 What uniform is Alexander Duncan McLennan wearing?
- 📝 Before iron was common, what did common people use for door hinges?
- 📝 What do historians mean when they say "divinity" in the context of Ancient Greece?
- 📝 How the average female body used to be before the industrial revolution?
- 📝 Is there a historical source that might explain why so many countries use 35 as a minimum age for the president / the highest office person?
- 📝 What factors related to the Eastern Crisis contributed to the outbreak of World War 1?
- 📝 Did American policymakers seriously consider scaling down Lend Lease Aid to the Soviet Union after the battle of Kursk?
- 📝 Which bank was the oldest surviving bank in the world prior to MPS getting that status?
- 📝 Where did the “vikings wear helmets with horn” stereotype come from and why?
- 📝 How did the US Navy raise sunken battleships in WWII?
- 📝 First US police officer killed in the line of duty
- 📝 Are Emil Ludwig's “Talks with Mussolini” reliable?
- 📝 What kind of uniform is this?
- 📝 Why did the US not move to crush the Haitian Revolt after the 1804 massacre?
- 📝 Have there been gay riots in the US?
- 📝 When Genghis Khan took power, what was the population of Mongolia?
- 📝 How did medieval architects determine sizes and numbers of pillars, buttresses etc?
- 📝 Did Japan make a contribution to World War II way out of proportion to its nominal relative GDP?
- 📝 Why is syncretism mostly described through an "interpretatio graeca", rather than any other polytheism?
- 📝 Did the founding fathers think civil wars would be frequent?
- 📝 Paradigm change in power: from military to economic in Europe
- 📝 Was there any politization of "hard" science (math, physics, chemistry, biology) in the Asian communist countries?
- 📝 When did we discover air?
- 📝 What led some people to (correctly) believe that there was no land under the ice cap at the North Pole?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How have estimates of the deaths in WWI and WWII changed over time?
- 📝 How has Chinese GDP as a percentage of world GDP changed over time and why?
- 📝 How many lives were estimated to have been saved by the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs?
- 📝 How did people say “I have to go to the bathroom” before the bathroom and pipes were common?
- 📝 How and why did Polish rule over the Ukraine "downwardly deviate" from Lithuanian rule?
- 📝 How have African countries kept the boundaries divided by colonists and countries unified for decades, despite the many ethnical groups and conflicts?
- 📝 How many trucks did Russia and Germany have at the start of Barbarossa?
- 📝 How did the British Army unit size and structure in WWI change from 1915 to 1918?
- 📝 How common was drug abuse and related deaths in the USA during the conservative 1950s?
- 📝 How much time did people have to take shelter during the Blitz in 1940-41?
- 📝 Have American writing styles changed between the Civil War and Today?
- 📝 How have the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki affected Japanese culture and language?
- 📝 Did Viet Nam suffer a famine any time during the 1980s? And if not, how close was it to famine?
- 📝 During and right after the French Revolution, how did France maintain and operate such a big army all over Europe?
- 📝 How did attitudes of German citizens toward Hitler and the Nazi Party change over the course of the pre-war and the post-war periods?
- 📝 Has the concept of "annulment" of a putative marriage changed over time in the Roman Catholic Church?
- 📝 How did Castro gain control over the Cuban military and police?
- 📝 How has enforcement of the USA-Mexico border changed over time?
- 📝 Did any nation have a demonstrable qualitative advantage in their soldiers of the 18th century, and how did they achieve this?
- 📝 How were Mercy Dogs of WWI and WWII trained to know which soldier is from their side and which one isn't?
- 📝 Why did no one take Siberia over before the Russians, and how did they do it?
- 📝 How many people died of hunger and malnutrition in the post WWII 20th century?
- 📝 What's the Ancient Egyptian phrase/word for “Royal Road of Life”? And how would it have been spelt?
- 📝 How many troops did the Confederate and Union army have in each year of the Civil War?
- 📝 Did people from the cities of Uruk, Ur and Sumer have knowledge/recollection of how old their cities were (say, recollection after 2000 BCE)?
- 📝 How do historians and linguists know how to pronounce the names from non-phonetic scripts?
- 📝 How and when did the word "nuclear" replace the word "atomic"?
- 📝 How did the USSR manage to innovate in an environment characterized by government censorship and high bureaucracy?
- 📝 If the Union Jack joins the flag of England and Scotland, why does it have a different shade of blue than the Scottish flag?
- 📝 When and how did the USA and the UK become allies?
