State boundaries in mountainous regions
score:3
I came across a passage from Colin McEvedy that went into this somewhat.
There is, of course, a conflict of interest between continental and littoral peoples but this does not become overt until the continental communities become organized into a centralized state. It is only then that the national aspirations are formulated and that there is a drive for 'natural frontiers', by which is simply meant geographically easily recognizable features such as rivers, mountain ranges or, best of all, the sea.
(from the introduction to The Penguin Atlas of Ancient History)
The dynamic you are seeing is simply that some peoples develop a culture that works in the mountains, and some don't. The same goes for rivers, and littoral areas. As a result, the peoples living on both sides of a river or mountain range tend to speak the same language. In Western and central Europe, the mountain and river people were often German speakers.
When leaders aspire to build borders for their territory, it is natural to want to do two things: 1) Encompass the entire area of your native culture and 2) Draw a line on a good defensible geographical feature.
What this tends to mean is that those based away from the geographic feature in question tend like to draw their border on it, while those based on the geographic feature would prefer to live in a country encompassing their compatriots on either side of the feature.
Upvote:5
I would argue against the premise. Which Switzerland is undeniably a mountainous region it still obeys the general rule of being on one side of a mountain. This map is a physical clue to what is going on, Switzerland is actually based around the Swiss Plateau, not around the alps.
If we reach back into history just before Switzerland came together into almost it's modern form, ie just before the Old Swiss Confederacy, we find it dominated by four main noble houses.
These are all very much on one side of the Swiss plateau, and this is still true today, with the "middle land" being where most of the Swiss population reside. While their influence now extends far into the mountains, I do not see this to be in conflict with your original observations about countries in the Carpathians.
However, of course I would agree that there is something special about their relation with the mountains. But I would be interested to know, for example, how Transylvania views the Carpathians, which forms a semi-circle around the region.
PS. I would point out the Gotthard Pass separates German and Italian speaking Swiss. And if that isn't a huge clue about people on opposite sides of mountain passes tending to be in different nations (not all national boundaries are political), I don't know what is.
More post
- ð Is there any valid basis for this claim that German Emperor Wilhelm II and the Hohenzollern family had Jewish blood?
- ð Has there ever been a serious effort to reform the US Electoral College system?
- ð What was the official currency used in North Carolina in 1814?
- ð Civilians in Napoleon's Grand Army when he invaded Russia
- ð Why did the communist party lose in Telangana in India's first general elections?
- ð Which country can be called the successor of the Roman Empire, after 476?
- ð In what countries were plague doctor masks were most common?
- ð Were Jews cut off from the Babylonian Geonim?
- ð What happened to the wealth of the Roman Catholic Church accumulated over the ages?
- ð Why was Africa never really colonized?
- ð Who are the "Two Parties" of the Protestants in the Treaty of Westphalia?
- ð Historically, was the War of 1812 ever called by another name?
- ð Vigenere vs. Bellaso
- ð Who is Swedens rightful king considering the coup d'etat of 1809 deposed the then rightful king?
- ð When in history did people start seeing a girl's breasts as being inherently sexual?
- ð What was the timetable for Germany's Invasion of the Low Countries (Fall Gelb) in WW2?
- ð Why did the Metall und Lackierwarenfabrik company get asked to bid on the creation of the MG42?
- ð What was the contemporary popular opinion of the Anglo-Irish Treaty?
- ð Why did the rest of the Eastern Bloc not invade Yugoslavia?
- ð Why did Mao use political mobilization to prevent inefficiency and slack?
- ð Did Nazi Germany conduct systematic experiments on prisoners on what it takes to kill/injure a human with electricity?
- ð What numerals did the people of Ireland use before Roman Numerals? (aka, did Ogham include numbers?)
- ð How secure was Germany's last foothold in the Caucasus in 1943?
- ð Financial ramifications of peerages created since the 19th century
- ð Why does Texas have the right to split?
- ð What were the logistics of the the Tehran Conference of 1943?
- ð What is this military patch with the silhouette of a pegasus on it?
- ð Were well-connected Germans able to park their sons in Norway during WWII?
- ð How were precise hand drawn illustrations copied between the 16th and 20th century in Europe?
- ð What is the historical origin of the story of the Temptation of Christ?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- ð State boundaries in mountainous regions
- ð When has a sovereign state last given territory to another as a gift?
- ð Has a state ever "attacked" another one by printing fake money?
- ð How did the Roman state verify citizenship?
- ð Did all the the -stan sovereign state names appear synchronously?
- ð Was the Dutch State independent when the Dutch East India Company was founded?
- ð Who had the shortest time in going from imprisonment to head of state within democratic processes?
- ð What was the state of the German rail system in 1944?
- ð What is the state of the art historical analysis of claims that Carthaginians discovered America?
- ð Did Noah Webster ever state why he Americanized spelling?
- ð Colonisation of India: Which regions of the United Kingdom did colonial personnel come from?
- ð What was this small state in the south of France in 1789?
- ð Why was Washington State an attractive site for aluminum production during World War II?
- ð Which Confederate State provided the most troops in the American Civil War?
- ð Was the option of setting up a Jewish state in defeated Nazi Germany ever considered?
- ð What is the current state of historical thought on the Aryan invasion/migration theory?
- ð Which state capital did the Apollo 11 command module NOT visit after it returned from the moon?
- ð Did Hitler really keep the blueprints of the current Nebraska state Capitol building in the drawer of his desk?
- ð Is "A state that is not able to feed itself...[is not]âĶa formidable foe" a quote by a historically known figure?
- ð In the United States government, has there been cases that electoral colleges don't vote for the candidate the majority of their state voted for?
- ð Was the State of Indiana's legislation changed to fix the value of Pi?
- ð State changing its name within the United States
- ð What Was the State of German Tank Design In Between the World Wars?
- ð Has there ever been a US election that flipped as many state seats as the 2010 midterm elections?
- ð What significant regions and countries became Muslim without being first conquered by a Muslim power?
- ð What proportion of the population of Soviet Union were taken into custody by the state during Stalin's time?
- ð How have African countries kept the boundaries divided by colonists and countries unified for decades, despite the many ethnical groups and conflicts?
- ð Apart from Australia, has a serving head of government or state disappeared without trace?
- ð Was there a US state where video games were banned by accident?
- ð At the start of Barbarossa, what was the state of Germany's oil supply?
