Question about mortal sin and the state of grace?
score:1
...is one better off than the other?
Yes, Catholics believe in "levels" both within Heaven and within Hell. Those in Heaven experience different "levels" of happiness and those in Hell experience different "levels" of suffering.
Thomas Aquinas responds to an objection which almost exactly parallels your question, and the Catholic Church has come to agree with his answer:
Objection 9. Further, just as some die in a state of grace and have some venial sins for which they deserve punishment, so some die in mortal sin and have some good for which they would deserve a reward. Now to those who die in grace with venial sins an abode is assigned where they are punished ere they receive their reward, which abode is purgatory. Therefore, on the other hand, there should be equally an abode for those who die in mortal sin together with some good works.
Reply to Objection 9. It is impossible for evil to be pure and without the admixture of good, just as the supreme good is without any admixture of evil. Consequently those who are to be conveyed to beatitude which is a supreme good must be cleansed of all evil. wherefore there must needs be a place where such persons are cleansed if they go hence without being perfectly clean. But those who will be thrust into hell will not be free from all good: and consequently the comparison fails, since those who are in hell can receive the reward of their goods, in so far as their past goods avail for the mitigation of their punishment.
(Summa Theologiae, Supplement, Question 69, Article 7, Reply to Objection 9)
The key sentence is, "...those who are in hell can receive the reward of their goods, in so far as their past goods avail for the mitigation of their punishment." The more good a damned soul has done, the more mitigated will be their punishment.
Upvote:1
Question about mortal sin and the state of grace?
Therefore whosoever shall eat this bread, or drink the chalice of the Lord unworthily, shall be guilty of the body and of the blood of the Lord. - 1 Corinthians 11:27
To receive Communion in the state of mortal sin is a far worse sin a sacrilege. To receive Communion in a unworthy manner adds the gravity of the soul’s sinfulness, for one has consumed the body and blood of Our Lord Jesus Christ, soul and divinity in the state of serious sin.
To receive any sacrament of the church (except baptism and penance) in mortal sin is to commit a sacrilege, which, as the Baltimore Catechism points out, is “a great sin, because it is an abuse of a sacred thing.” However, receiving the Eucharist in an unworthily manner also brings about judgment, as explained in the Bible as well as contemplated by some of the great saints and fathers of the church.
“Whoever eats the bread and drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily will have to answer for the body and blood of the Lord. A person should examine himself, and so eat the bread and drink the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body, eats and drinks judgment on himself. That is why many among you are ill and infirm, and a considerable number are dying.” (I Cor. 11:27-30)
Saint Paul did not pull any punches when he warned of the dangers of receiving the Eucharist when you are in a state of grave sin. Saint Paul did not treat the reception of the Eucharist as a “right” or an “obligation because everyone else is doing it”. He did not treat the Eucharist as bread and wine. He did not treat the Eucharist as a “routine” and “something I have do to.” He treated it as Jesus. He treated it as the Real Presence of the Son of God and warned against mistreating it. When you receive the Eucharist in an unworthy manner you are mistreating the body and blood of Jesus Christ. Just because one does not believe in the transubstantiation does not make it untrue. One’s unbelief does not make the truth a lie. It only brings forth judgment and danger upon the unbeliever.
Canon Law 916 addresses this by stating that a person “conscious of grave sin” should not “receive the body of the Lord without previous sacramental confession.” The Canon Law places an obligation on each individual to seriously take an examination of your conscious and your soul before receiving the Eucharist. Just because you are at Mass does not mean you must receive the Eucharist and just because you have always received it each week does not mean you have to receive it if you are in a state of grave sin.
As Catholics, we must get away from just going through the motions and making Jesus a routine. If the Eucharist is sacred enough for us to genuflect before a tabernacle, pray and kneel in its presence during Adoration and profess it as the source and summit of the Christian life then we must know and confess it is more than a routine. It is more than a right. It is more than an entitlement. It is Jesus Christ and it is the body, blood, soul and divinity of the Son of God, of God Incarnate, which we receive. - The Grave Danger of Receiving the Eucharist Unworthily
To receive Communion in an unworthy manner is a more serious sin in the eyes of the Catholic Church.
More post
- 📝 What's the basic premise behind "restorationist" movements?
- 📝 Under what conditions does the Catholic Church explicitly call the laity extraordinary ministers?
- 📝 Do any denominations accept their own part in the failure, generally, of Christendom, to rise to the reality of what Christianity ought to be?
- 📝 Why was having concubines not a sin like adultery?
- 📝 What is the most sexually liberal church denomination?
- 📝 Are there any major Protestant denominations that have rejected salvation by faith alone?
- 📝 What does being lukewarm mean in contrast with being hot or cold for the church of Laodicea?
- 📝 Why does Jesus say "Why have you forsaken me?"
- 📝 Why don't Presbyterians have altars?
- 📝 What is the evidence that suggests that the Apostle Paul was married?
- 📝 How do distant starlight & white holes support Young Earth Creationism?
- 📝 Do those who pray to saints ascribe to them the quality of being able to hear many people at once?
- 📝 Can a Sovereign-will authorize personal liberty?
- 📝 What is the basis for the doctrine of the Trinity in the Book of Mormon?
- 📝 Are these verses from Proverbs contradictory?
- 📝 Why doesn't the Catholic Church give indulgences to everybody, regardless of their works?
- 📝 What is the Vatican's position on ISIS?
- 📝 If someone is forced to take the punishment for sin (Jesus), doesn't that mean that God never forgives?
- 📝 What are the different meanings of “God” in the New Testament?
- 📝 How long can the Catholic Church be without a pope?
- 📝 According to Catholicism, what are angels and what are they for?
- 📝 What is the origin of "Jesus H Christ"?
- 📝 Catholics marrying after civil divorce
- 📝 The Wretched Word "Miser"
- 📝 Are there any Antipope Saints aside from Hippolytus of Rome?
- 📝 What does Origen mean in his response when Celsus accuses Christ' of using black magic when performing miracles? What is the actual argument?
- 📝 Why was a sign being sought?
- 📝 Psalm 144:5 Bow Your heavens, O LORD, and come down; Touch the mountains, that they may smoke
- 📝 What is the difference between Evangelical and Protestant?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for multiple judgments after death?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Question about mortal sin and the state of grace?
- 📝 When did the Catholic Church first distinguish mortal from venial sin and connect it to state of grace?
- 📝 Is participation in the near occasion of mortal sin and openness to the possibility of sin, mortal itself?
- 📝 If we receive infinite grace through bread and wine as the Catholic theology say, why does a person still sin against God?
- 📝 Question about a mixed metaphor and the argument from causation
- 📝 A question about the difference between men and women
- 📝 Biblical basis for the separation of church and state
- 📝 If both the Orthodox and Catholic Church affirm salvation by grace through faith, why did the Protestant Reformation happen?
- 📝 Does the Bible itself give us clues about which parts to interpret literally and which figuratively?
- 📝 What does the LDS Church (Mormon) teach about marriage and polygamy in the afterlife?
- 📝 What has the LDS Church (Mormons) historically taught about the Curse of Cain and dark skin?
- 📝 Why Do Moses' Laws About Slavery and Punishment Not Align with the Teachings of Jesus?
- 📝 God created male and female.... What about those who do not fit in the box?
- 📝 What do Quakers believe about war and serving in the military?
- 📝 What is the Catholic understanding of the first sin committed by Adam and Eve?
- 📝 What about the story of the "Rich Man and Lazarus" indicates whether it is a parable or not?
- 📝 How do the Catholic and Orthodox views of original sin differ?
- 📝 Did the church fathers or OT talk about the visible and invisible church?
- 📝 What is the basis for the idea that the Song of Solomon is about the relationship between God and the church?
- 📝 Did the disagreement between the Catholic Church and Protestant Church on the issue of salvation by grace alone end in 1999?
- 📝 According to the Catholic Church, does abortion need to be confessed, and is it a mortal or venial sin?
- 📝 Does the seal of confession apply even when the sin is intended and there is no desire to repent?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for venial and mortal sins?
- 📝 What does the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints teach about who Jesus is and where He came from?
- 📝 What does the LDS Church teach about Jesus being married, having children, and His position on polygamy?
- 📝 What does the LDS church teach about what men and women did or do in the pre-existence?
- 📝 For Catholics who have expressed concern about Pope Francis and are wary of his pontificate, what are the key issues?
- 📝 What was St. Thomas Aquinas's view on the difference between punishment accorded to original sin and punishment accorded to individual sin?
- 📝 What does the Bible say about this question- Why do Jesus and God have two seats in heaven when they are the same God?
- 📝 Was Adam mortal before he partook of the tree of knowledge of good and evil?
