Was Otto Carius fair in his assessment of American forces vs. Russians?
score:12
You'll hear stuff like this from time to time, but really it is more just reflecting the US way of war. The Germans fought on the cheap, and they wanted to win fast, so they mixed it up. The US had the philosophy that there was always plenty of artillery or air support or tanks on call, so when resistance was hit, why not expend some shells before going in? The effectiveness was not in doubt, since despite all his sneering Otto was still the one inside the pocket. And if he had tried to drive out, he likely would have found the dominant Allied air support blowing his tank away without an infantryman having to lift a finger.
Upvote:-1
At a low level I doubt there would have been much difference between the average American/British/Russian/German soldier by early 1945 due to the simple fact that casualty rates were so high for all armies that they were scrounging up whoever could hold a rifle and point it in generally the right direction.
Really the primary difference between Eastern and Western fronts was that the former was more generally no-holds barred. If the other guy is pretty confident that you aren't taking prisoners he will fight that much harder...
Working your way up the chain the average US officer commanding a formation larger than say a battalion was likely less apt than his Russian or British counterpart, but that can be explained by the fact that in Europe the US Army didn't suffer from very many significant defeats after the unfortunate events at Kasserine Pass in 1943. Without the kind of "evolutionary pressure" that pushes the likes of a Montgomery and Zhukov to the top you can't expect excellence.
Upvote:0
This is one man's subjective view, albeit a professional's. And the guy was riding in a Tiger tank with an 88mm gun (or was it a "Jagdtiger" with a 128mm main gun?). And then he might just have faced infantry or inexperienced fresh units. At the beginning of the war in the Soviet Union, the Germans captured hundreds of thousands of soldiers, until the Red Army adapted it's tactics and training.
Upvote:11
"The poorer the infantry, the more artillery it needs; the American infantry needs all it can get." French General Koechlin-Schwartz, speaking to U.S. General George S. Patton on two occasions. "The Patton Papers, 1940-1945"; George Smith Patton, Martin Blumenson; Houghton Mifflin (1972); pp.520-521
American troops were inexperienced and poor, especially in comparison with the German veterans who survived the Eastern front. What's so surprising here?
Additionally, as mentioned by @Oldcat, American forces had sufficient air support and artillery making infantry skills less critical.
On the other hand, Russian soldiers (and, to a lesser degree, officers, and, to even lesser degree, generals), were quite good, and better yet by the end of the war. They were second only to the German ones, and only until 1943 (1944?)
This seems to be obscured by the perceived poor performance of the Red Army against the Finns (remember, SU won the war despite the apauling conditions favoring the defenders) and horrible defeats that Red Army suffered at the hands of Wehrmacht in 1941-1942 (when the Wehrmacht was in the prime of its shape, battle hardened, experienced, supplied by almost the whole Europe).
See also my answer to another question.
More post
- π Why didn't Iran declare war on the United States for shooting down flight-655?
- π Are many Russians descended from Varangian Vikings?
- π Can someone identify this coin? Ξ€ΞΞΞ‘ΞΞΞ(Ξ₯) (Ξ)ΞΞ£ΞΞΞΞ©(Ξ£)
- π Was von Manstein's Lack of Success at Leningrad (and later Stalingrad) due to the failure of German military intelligence?
- π How much faster/better were European printing presses compared to Chinese block printing?
- π Why didn't Japan attack communist China in WW2?
- π Did Japan ever retaliate for the Russian attacks of 1806?
- π Why did Napoleon change his mind and continue the attack into Russia?
- π How can Germany be blamed for World War 1?
- π How much faster were the printing presses than hand writing?
- π Can anyone help me identify this coin?
- π Why did Michigan abolish capital punishment so early?
- π How to understand the geography of Napoleon's military campaigns?
- π Tolstoy's view of history
- π Why did Nepal and Bhutan not become a part of India like other princely states when colonial rule ended?
- π How heavy were the heaviest war hammers actually used?
- π Were major foreign films allowed in the USSR?
- π What lead some nationalities to be the butt of be*t**lity jokes?
- π Did Aboriginal Australians know slings?
- π Why were Morocco and Tunisia made a French protectorate, but Algeria annexed as part of France?
- π How did Britain rule Sri Lanka?
- π Is there any research explicitly contradicting facts in Suvorov's "Icebreaker" book series claiming that Stalin intended to attack Hitler in 1941?
- π Did the Hungarian Army ever use crescent banners?
- π How accurate is Nietzsche's account of the birth of tragedy?
- π Did the Babylonians know the Pythagorean Theorem before Pythagoras formulated it?
- π Was game theory used during World War II?
- π Given Hitler's Austrian ancestry, why did he develop German nationalism rather than Austrian nationalism?
- π What did Vikings wear in cold wet conditions at sea?
- π How do we know the tonnages U-boats sank?
- π What biographical information do we know about author Frank Rudolph Young?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π Was Otto Carius fair in his assessment of American forces vs. Russians?
- π Was there a battle were Russians forces rallied around a religious icon to achieve victory?
- π Did Adolf Hitler ever address the fact that his own appearance was almost an exact opposite of what he considered the ideal Aryan appearance?
- π Is there any evidence to support the claim that the United States was "suckered into WW1" by Zionists, made by Benjamin Freedman in his 1961 speech?
- π Was murdering a slave illegal in American slavery, and if so, what punishments were given for it?
- π Was the American Civil War the βbloodiest civil war in historyβ?
- π Was swordsmanship important in the American Civil War?
- π Was the concept of religious freedom in the early United States applied to native American faiths?
- π To what extent was prohibition supported by the American public?
- π By mid-1945, was Japan capable of maintaining the war even in the absence of further direct American attacks?
- π When was the American War of Independence first called a 'Revolution'?
- π Was there a pre-determined arrangement for the division of Germany in case it surrendered before any Soviet forces entered its territory?
- π What was the Victorian opinion of the American Revolution?
- π Who was this Roman General/figure of authority who, on his deathbed, named these two regrets?
- π Was being in the KKK politically/socially acceptable in early 1900's American South?
- π Was there a "secret" recording of the American founding fathers' deliberations?
- π Why was Reagan sworn in twice for his second term?
- π Was King Henry VIII, mid-late in his reformation campaign, motivated more by theology or absolutist drive?
- π How common was it for un-documented ships to bring settlers to the American colonies 1700-1750
- π Was the Somerset Decision in 1772 in England the real underlying cause of the American Revolutionary war?
- π Based on his service record, where was this soldier deployed in WW2?
- π If Bill Clinton was impeached, why did he finish his second term?
- π Did American forces specifically target officers during the revolutionary war?
- π Was there any genuine debate in the pre-1860 United States regarding Native American sovereignty?
- π Is it true that slavery was banned from discussion on the Senate and/or House floor before the American Civil War?
- π Did Sir Isaac Newton ever claim that his mind in 1666 was "remarkably fit for invention"?
- π To what extent does the dictionary of Samuel Johnson represent English as it was spoken in his day?
- π Was the Church of St Simeon the Elder at Aleppo built while Simeon was still alive or decades after his death?
- π Was the king of England able to execute a high rank noble and his family between 1216 and 1688?
- π What was the first documented mention of American English different from British English?
