Was the title "Prince of Wales" originally claimed for the English crown prince via a trick?
score:31
tl;dr: No, at least not in the sense suggested.
The earliest source of something akin to this story, seems to be the 1584 Historie of Cambria, now called Wales, the first printed history of Wales. The author, a Welsh cleric called David Powel, wrote that:
He called the Welshmen togither, declaring unto them, that whereas they were oftentimes suters unto him to appoint them a Prince, he now having occasion to depart out of the countrie, would name them a Prince, if they would allow and obey him whom he should name. To the which motion they answered that they would so doo, if he would appoint one of their owne nation to be their Prince: whereunto the king replied, that he would name one that was borne in Wales, and could speake never a word of English, whose life and conversation no man was able to staine. And when they all had granted that such a one they would obey, he named his owne sonne Edward borne in Caernarvon castell a few daies before.
While this is clearly trickery, given that this account was written three centuries after the events in question, it is generally not considered credible.
Moreover, even in Powel's version, there is no mention of any peace settlement that may necessitate such trickery. Indeed, there was in fact no peace settlement in that war: Edward brutally executed Llywelyn's successor Dafydd, imprisoned most of their relatives for life, and generally went out of his way to destroy the ancient House of Aberffraw. It was a war of conquest and annexation.
In conclusion, there is no evidence to corroborate the specific version of events, as the story described in the question. Nonetheless, the idea that Edward might have thought to use his son's birth in Wales for political capital is not farfetched.
Upvote:5
It does seem to be a myth, but one that's been around for a few hundred years. This is briefly discussed in the Wikipedia article for Edward II, which notes:
David Powel, a 16th-century clergyman, suggested that the baby was offered to the Welsh as a prince "that was borne in Wales and could speake never a word of English", but there is no evidence to support this account.[15]
Sadly the article doesn't go into any detail about this, but it does suggest the sources dismiss it conclusively. The citation here is to two recent academic-press biographies of Edward II (Seymour Phillips, 2011, and Roy Haines, 2003).
Powel's version of the myth can be seen in this 1811 edition of Historie of Cambria. It's not clear exactly where he took it from; this particular section was "collected for the most part out of the records in the Tower", rather than being attributed to Cronica Walliae or other Welsh sources.
Interestingly, the same book seems to be responsible for popularising another common myth - that of the Welsh discovery of America by Madoc in the twelfth century.
More post
- 📝 America vs. Australia as a "Penal Colony"
- 📝 Why was Stalin chosen as the First General Secretary in 1922?
- 📝 Why didn't Japanese attack Soviet Union simultaneously as the Germans?
- 📝 What was that book that listed all the rich/influential people and defined socioeconomic status for many Americans?
- 📝 Why did Japan not withdraw from China as its pacific front was crumbling and the threat of US invasion imminent?
- 📝 Was there a Princess of Wales between 1727 and 1736?
- 📝 What's the difference between Kosovo's & the Confederate States of America's declaration of independence?
- 📝 Communication lag during the Age of Sail: what if enemy claimed that peace agreement was signed?
- 📝 Mnemonics for centures or any other longer periods, like Zodiac signs other than Chinese?
- 📝 What was the estimated population of the Mississippi Valley before contact with Europeans?
- 📝 Upper-class male cohabitation in mid-19th century USA
- 📝 How flexible is kinship taxonomy in Jewish communities?
- 📝 What in Confucianism reduced the importance of the clan structure and made these societies more secular?
- 📝 Am I imagining this or did I just found one of the oldest "hidden" erotic artworks ever?
- 📝 Was Frederick II of Hohenstaufen really a medieval Dr. Mengele?
- 📝 Were there interstate tariffs before the US Constitution (1789)?
- 📝 Did Martin Luther King's political outlook change during the civil rights movement?
- 📝 How were Roman Legions disarmed/disbanded before entering Italia?
- 📝 What alternate north-south supply routes did the Soviet Union have when the Volga and Stalingrad were under attack?
- 📝 When and why was Seleucia ultimately abandoned?
- 📝 Why did the Schlieffen Plan prioritize invading France?
- 📝 Where did Roman senators mostly live in the time of Tiberius or Caligula?
- 📝 When did Vladivostok become usable year-round?
- 📝 How did Rome's legal system work?
- 📝 How were tanks scrapped after World War Two?
- 📝 Did Crusaders' siege Nablus and then massacre Muslims?
- 📝 What impact did Trotsky's armoured train have on the Russian civil war?
- 📝 Cabin space on the Nadezhda
- 📝 Why did ramming reappear then disappear in 1800s shipborn warfare?
- 📝 Where is the other surviving chest from the Boston Tea Party?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Was the title "Prince of Wales" originally claimed for the English crown prince via a trick?
- 📝 What was the reaction to English monarchs using the title "King of France"?
- 📝 Why was "Caesar" borrowed for the imperial title in German rather than "Augustus"?
- 📝 Why was the "first Monday in December" originally chosen as the default meeting date for Congress?
- 📝 During the breakup of the Soviet Union, on what basis was citizenship granted or withheld for each of the fifteen new republics?
- 📝 Was it militarily possible to "island hop" the Philippines if not for MacArthur?
- 📝 What was the reason for Soviet troops to withdraw from Yugoslavia in World War II?
- 📝 If the Ch’in dynasty was so short-lived, why was China named for it?
- 📝 Is there evidence to suggest the "war on drugs" was a cover for class warfare?
- 📝 What was the plan for an abort of the Enola Gay's mission to drop the atomic bomb?
- 📝 What was the economic basis for West Berlin?
- 📝 Was there a tax in the fifties for British citizens traveling abroad?
- 📝 Was it ever possible to join the US military instead of going to prison for a crime?
- 📝 What was the planned line of succession for the Nazi Party in the event that Hitler died?
- 📝 Was it possible for a young Japanese woman to end up enslaved in Great Britain in the mid-1600s?
- 📝 What was the 1970s name for skinny jeans?
- 📝 Who was responsible for the partition of India?
- 📝 Why was the area now known as Liberia chosen as the location for repatriation of African slaves in the US?
- 📝 Was Hiroshima targeted because its mountains would "rebound the explosion back into the city for more damage"?
- 📝 Was the "natural born citizen" requirement for the President inserted into the US Constitution by Alexander Hamilton's enemies?
- 📝 Was there a pre-determined arrangement for the division of Germany in case it surrendered before any Soviet forces entered its territory?
- 📝 Was the use of captured tanks an effective strategy for Germany?
- 📝 What was it like for a coastal village to experience a Viking raid in around the tenth century?
- 📝 What English company founded in the 1200s filed for bankruptcy in the 2000s?
- 📝 What was the original process for becoming a US citizen?
- 📝 Who was the English Knight Templar holding command in the Mongol Army?
- 📝 Was Islam really responsible for the Italian Renaissance?
- 📝 In the first half of 20th century, how was gold inspected for authenticity?
- 📝 Was the act of servicemen exchanging their weapons for enemy weapons common during WWII?
- 📝 What was the motivation for the Gregorian Calendar?
