Could medieval soldiers be organized into a Roman style legion order of battle?
Upvote:3
Long time ago I wondered about the same. I always thought the Roman army (early imperial, of course) would beat the crap out of any opponent until the end of the middle ages. After learning a lot about history I had to change my opinion completely.
No. 1: The Roman army was entirely professional. From the lowest recruit up to generals in command. Medieval armies were definitely not. That was a professional cadre (nobles, knights and possibly sergeants) leading drafted poorly equipped and poorly trained peasants. And poorly led, certainly in the eyes of Roman professionals.
No. 2: Logistics. That concept went completely down the drain after the fall of Rome in the West. (Do mind that the Byzantine army was a continuation of the Roman army with excellent logistics and survived a millennium). For a professional army you need a lot more than pack a lunch.
It's there that medieval armies fell short. It was something they simply couldn't do, no matter what. You need supplies for the army in the field. Transportation to get it there. Folks back home producing food, arms, uniforms and equipment. I leave out medical services, medieval armies weren't very strong in that department. No medieval state except for Byzantium was capable of doing that.
It took about a year to train a Roman recruit to be a basic legionary. During that year they did nothing else but train. They had to eat now and then, meaning that someone else had to grow the food, harvest it and get it to the legion. Once trained and professional, they had to keep training to remain fighting fit. You can't be a farmer and a professional legionary. It's either - or. Medieval states had no capability for that. Rome and Byzantium did.
Another very important point here: if you hire soldiers full time, until they have to retire due to (relatively) old age at 40-50, you take their best and most profitable years. That means you have to provide them with some sort of pension. That was within medieval society completely impossible.
3- (Very) early medieval armies actually were (very) late Roman armies.
The Roman army varied over time. It adapted itself to the enemies it had to face. From a hoplite army suitable to fight local wars into a more cavalry based relatively mobile army at the end.
During the battle of Chalons against the Huns the Roman army was present but didn't do much. Even Aelius didn't think they were of much use other than be an obstacle. A rather inglorious end for the probably best army ever...
Upvote:5
NO.
The Roman army was made up of "professional" soldiers, who served 25 years (from their late teens to their early 40s, like modern ball players), before they were disbanded. No medieval armies had soldiers of this standing, although the Kommenians came closer than others.
This started after the Punic Wars, when cheap grain acquired from Sicily (and other points south of Rome) "dispossessed" the sturdy yeoman farmers. They had to find other pursuits, with the military being one of the more obvious ones, hence the Roman practice of "career" soldiers.
The feudal societies of medieval Europe had no "Sicilies" to produce surplus grain, meaning that essentially all of their men were needed for farming, and only a handful of nobles could afford to be "professional" soldiers. Imagine an army where only the officers were professional, and essentially all of the recruits (95% of the army) had less than a year of training and experience, and were basically recruited for a single battle. That was the difference between Roman and medieval armies.
More post
- 📝 Can anyone tell me what style of sword this is?
- 📝 Did the Socialist and the Fascist party share the electoral programme in Italy?
- 📝 Why was Operation Felix cancelled?
- 📝 Was respiratory rate used as time measurement?
- 📝 Was mortality higher on French slave ships and if so, why?
- 📝 On what basis do some historians accuse the British government of genocide during the great Irish famine?
- 📝 What is the source and history of "green on blue attack" expression?
- 📝 Are there any images from ancient times in which Heracles is shown with a cornucopia?
- 📝 Why didn't the linguistic split overlap with the religion split in Prussian Silesia?
- 📝 Have any large scale cultural or ideological shifts ever been successfully reversed by those who opposed it?
- 📝 Was there ever a treaty between 2 entities with significantly different translations to the detriment of one party?
- 📝 What was considered an epoch by the Phoenicians?
- 📝 What was the policy on academic research being published beyond the iron curtain?
- 📝 Does the leather strap often depicted on a Pith helmets serve a purpose, or is it purely cosmetic?
- 📝 What prevented empires with territory in North Africa from expanding south of the Sahara? And vice versa
- 📝 How do we reconcile hierarchical and violent aspects of Ancient Egypt with its nonviolent principle of Maat, as exemplified in negative confessions?
- 📝 Was the date skip of the Gregorian calender reform understood to skip weekdays accordingly?
- 📝 Why could China keep most of the lands it conquered after 17th century but European powers could not?
- 📝 How do new countries legally and without bloodshed declare themselves independent?
- 📝 Why didn't the British Grand Fleet force an engagement with the German Imperial Navy in WW1?
- 📝 Classical battle sizes vs medieval battle sizes
- 📝 What are Kottabos players holding in their left hand?
- 📝 Have American urban rioters ever looted residences?
- 📝 What is the title of a medieval mayor?
- 📝 What route did the Hindenburg take when traveling from Germany to the U.S.?
- 📝 When did the Portuguese decide to extend their West African exploration to finding a sea passage to India?
- 📝 Was the Titanic tragedy at least partly avoidable?
- 📝 Why does the Spanish Military Medical Corps use the Amalfitan Cross?
- 📝 Life in the middle ages for ordinary people?
- 📝 What major approaches to "class" as a theoretical category do historians commonly use?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Could medieval soldiers be organized into a Roman style legion order of battle?
- 📝 What did the battle order of a deployed Roman legion look like?
- 📝 How could the Roman sestertii/sesterces be converted into modern terms (say 2017 US$)?
- 📝 Could women be crucified under Roman law?
- 📝 Were Medieval Britons aware of the existence of the Roman Empire?
- 📝 In the Battle of the Coral Sea, how could two Japanese scouts grossly mis-identify two American ships?
- 📝 WW2: Did US marines and soldiers really go into action with unbuckled helmet chin straps?
- 📝 How could Jews integrate into Western modern society back when Saturday was a normal working day?
- 📝 Classical battle sizes vs medieval battle sizes
- 📝 How difficult was to escape from a naval battle after engaging into one during the Age of Sail?
- 📝 Did the Celts really go into battle naked?
- 📝 Could the Russians Have Done Better at the Battle of Tsushima Straits Than They Actually Did?
- 📝 When did the Roman Forum fall into disuse?
- 📝 How quickly could the Roman legions march? How did it compare to their cavalry?
- 📝 Were Roman gladiators ever enlisted into the military?
- 📝 Did the Roman Empire extend as far north as the Romans could grow wine?
- 📝 Was the Battle of Tours really the turning point for the Umayyad expansion into Europe?
- 📝 Could a person get from the outer districts of Vienna into the city center via the sewage system?
- 📝 At the Battle of Zama, was the Roman army more "native" than the Carthaginian?
- 📝 What Roman Republican legal structures lasted into the Empire and which ones didn't?
- 📝 Could senators visit Roman Egypt?
- 📝 Health precautions before going into Battle of Trafalgar and other battles
- 📝 What Roman legions in Hispania revolted against Caesar before the battle at Munda?
- 📝 How was the Roman army in fact organized during Caesar's campaigns in Gaul?
- 📝 Which Roman general was killed by his own soldiers for not letting them to loot a newly conquered city?
- 📝 What was the significance of the BEF moving into the gap between German forces in First Battle of the Marne?
- 📝 How did Soviet soldiers resist tanks during the battle of Shumshu?
- 📝 Inquiry into the nature and roots of the temporal power of the Roman Catholic Pope:
- 📝 Roman Legion composition
- 📝 Could besieged medieval cities develop a micro-economy during wars to endure the siege for long time?
