Where did Hannibal cross the Pyrenees?
score:27
This is a subject of some dispute, but perhaps the most common view is that Hannibal probably crossed the Pyrenees via the mountain passes of modern Le Perthus.
He crossed the Pyrenees by the Col du Perthus, a relatively low pass near the eastern end of the mountains near the Mediterranean Sea. The Col du Oethus is less than 800 meters high and even in ancient times was an easy passage over the mountains.
- Prevas, John. Hannibal Crosses the Alps: the Invasion of Italy and the Punic Wars. Da Capo Press, 2009.
This is inferred from historical records. In his Histories, the Greek historian Polybius described Hannibal's passage through the Pyrenees as:
From Emporium to Narbo it is about six hundred stades ... this part of the road having now been carefully measured by the Romans and marked with milestones at every eighth stade (3:39:8).
This suggests that Polybius thought Hannibal followed an ancient route, one that the Romans later surveyed and paved as the Via Domitia. The Via Domitia leads into Iberia (where it links up with the Via Augusta) through the Col de Parnissars and its neighbouring Col du Perthus, both to the west of the Albères. During antiquity these were the main passes across the Pyrenees, and it would have been perfectly sensible for Hannibal to make his crossing here as well
The Via Domitia leads to the most popular (and lowest) pass in the eastern Pyrenees, the Col de Panissars, now known as the Col de Portus. Hannibal probably came through this pass in 218 BC.
- Salisbury, J. E. Rome's Christian Empress: Galla Placidia Rules at the Twilight of the Empire. JHU Press, 2015.
Another possibility on the Via Domitia route was the Col de Banyuls, which was closer to the Mediterranean coast. Some have suggested that Hannibal might have crossed here, but this is not considered likely because it would make the Carthaginians much more likely to be noticed.
The exact pass or passes by which the army went over the eastern spurs of the Pyrenees is not known, but J. Colin was of opinion that it was by the Col de Banyuls, about 360 metres high, 37 kilometres from Emporiae and 33 to Illiberis (Elne).
- De Beer, Gavin. Hannibal: Challenging Rome's Supremacy. Viking Press, 1969.
Both options are in the Eastern Pyrenees, a not inconsiderable distance from Andorra.
In addition to the Via Domitia passes, the other theory is that Hannibal crossed at the Col de Perche in the Central Pyrenees. This route, through the basin of the Segre as mentioned in the question, would indeed bring Hannibal close to Andorra, as the question's alternative hypothesis argues. However, it makes relatively less sense for Hannibal to choose this unnecessarily difficult path.
The main arguments for this route is that Hannibal may have chosen it so that he could defeat the nearby tribes. The military and strategic benefits of such a move is dubious, though. If the Carthaginians had any hopes for maintaining a logistical link to Spain, it was dashed within months.
Upvote:0
The Segre River from the tribe of the Ilergetes makes a lot of sense as a secondary route. In fact, the route follows, for the most part, the tribal lands of the Aerenosii and Andosini. It is mentioned by Polybius that Hannibal conquered tribes north of the Iber and as far as the Pyrenees. We don't have any mention of the Ceretani (Cerdanya) as well as the Indigetes (Indika/Ullastret). How would Hannibal make it through Col de Perthus unnoticed by the Indigetes especially the Banyuls pass?
Furthermore, it is not entirely impossible to reach Ilerberris (Elne) or Perpignan from the Segre River basin. The River Tet reaches Perpignan, not too far north of Elne. As well, River Le Tech (from Elne) to the Col d'Ares (Aerenosii?) in today's Nord Catalunya. The only issue is that Andosini (Andorra) is too far east. Perhaps Andosini and Aerenosii are tribes further to the east in the Pyrenees? The difficulty is the Ilergetes who at one time were allied with the Carthaginians and they are clearly just barely north of Ebro River along the Segre River basin. Why would Hannibal even bother with them if they are so far west away from the route taken?
Upvote:2
Looking at ancient warfare strategy and tactics, it's likely Hannibal used two different routes through the Central Pyrenees. Any other option is unlikely as Hannibal had enemies on the North side and South side of the Eastern Pyrenees. The river Segre is the most promising as the secondary route.
Upvote:2
Living in the area, I've taken on board these comments and others. My background is geographic, following what sparse evidence there is and local legends I'm surveying all five possible routes.
Col de Panissars/Perthus is accepted locally as the most likely and certainly it's the most direct. Col de Banyuls has local claims as the crossing point for Hercules who was something of a reference for Hannibal. Puigcedra is the most interesting. There are thin claims finds at Tossal de Beltaga support that route based it seems there are of signs of destruction around that time?? It's an interesting idea and certainly its a reasonably easy early summer route to Perpignan and Elne.
There are issues regarding the absolute embargo on staying south of the Tech but that could be managed. The local thinking it was not the entire army but a substantial portion. https://fundacionpalarq.com/en/hannibal-and-his-troops-pass-through-the-pyrenees/
Upvote:3
Polybius clearly states the route - Ilergetes (the people of Ilerda, now Lleida) which is slightly north-east of the Ebro river and where the Segre (Sicoris) River flows through. He mentions the Aeronosii or Aierenossi which is interesting as Val d'Aran is mostly associated with this tribe, perhaps the region of Val d'Aran is just a region within the tribal lands of what are the Aeronosii as there are sufficient placenames near Andorra towards Sort with the Ares, Arros, Arreau, similarities.
Or, he managed to take two separate paths to ensure the protection of one contingent if the other was ambushed going through the Pyrenean passes. Val d'Aran would be a good choice, it's far away from any Roman influence of the time (Lugdunum Convenae or St Bertrand de Comminges) was not under Roman control.
Aside from Val d'Aran, Polybius mentions the Bargusii which is often and wrongly referred to Barcelona. Next is Andosini which is most likely Andorra and is derived from an Iberian term Andes or Indes (Indigetes) similarities and then Ceretani (Cerdanya).
All the place names Polybius mentions are within the Segre River basin. We also must remember the Ilergetes and Celtiberians nearby were, at one time, allied with the Carthaginians and they were sent to Carthage, Utica, as well as Sicily. The Ilergetes' alliance to Carthage was very well devised scheme by Hannibal and Hasdrubal.
Upvote:5
I am quite surprised that nobody mentionned Livy's History of Rome Ab Urbe Condita. In book 21 - parts 23 and 24, the historian says about Hannibal that:
- He placed Hanno in charge of the whole coast-line to secure the passes which connect Spain with Gaul
- He crossed the Pyrenees with the remainder of his force and fixed his camp at the town of Iliberri.
Illiberri is modern-day Elne. If Livy is to be believed, then it would seem very awkward to secure the coastline, cross far away near Urgell and then go to Elne. Securing the coastline means he crossed at Le Perthus or Banyuls, probably not Urgell.
I might even say that from Empuries to Elne, it is more straightforward to cross at Banyuls. On the other hand, given that he then wanted to meet Gaulish leaders in Ruscino (near modern-day Perpignan) who were skeptical about him, he may have taken the way through Le Perthus, then towards Ruscino, but was obliged to step aside in Illiberris, given the opposition in Ruscino.
More post
- 📝 Communist Party member Stances on Molotov Ribbentrop Soviety German Treaty
- 📝 Why are there so few twins in political history?
- 📝 What is this medal that LBJ is wearing?
- 📝 How did coach service in 18th century America work?
- 📝 What's the difference between Route Army and Army Group?
- 📝 Was anyone a notable participant in both the American Revolution and the Latin American Wars of Independence (as a liberator)?
- 📝 What started the Korean war?
- 📝 What resources did the Nahua value most at the time of Spanish conquest?
- 📝 When did the use of fabricated speeches in historical works go out of fashion?
- 📝 During the 1930-40s - World War 2 - were children taught English in Nazi Germany?
- 📝 Does Siquieros' Echo of a Scream resemble a known news photo from the Second Sino-Japanese War?
- 📝 Do revolutions always need public support in order to succeed long-term?
- 📝 Do Real Roman and Greek warriors have big muscles and six-pack abs like in the movie?
- 📝 Have famous rabbis ever converted to Islam?
- 📝 Examples of wars without power as a motive
- 📝 When did chairs with arms and backs develop in Europe?
- 📝 Were sermons in the Middle Ages devoted to Old Testament or New Testament subjects?
- 📝 Why has the 18th and not the 19th century come to be called „the age of reason“?
- 📝 Did Stephen the Great know about the discovery of the New World?
- 📝 Were hag stones ever engraved?
- 📝 What was Asir's role in the Arab Revolt?
- 📝 How was 19th century ship tonnage reported?
- 📝 How did Porfirio Diaz leave Mexico for Europe?
- 📝 Has anyone recently seen Chinese old customary greeting pose?
- 📝 Why and when did countries develop long names that include the form of government?
- 📝 Did Aboriginal Australians know slings?
- 📝 Are there any records of Vikings burning each others 'island of boats' out of desperation?
- 📝 When could California mission priests perform confirmation?
- 📝 Which 1848 German revolutionaries became key players in the US Republican party?
- 📝 Has a country gone to war to seek payment of a debt since 1900?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Where did Hannibal cross the Pyrenees?
- 📝 Why did Columbus cross the mid-Atlantic instead of exploring from Greenland?
- 📝 Where did the Romans store their cash?
- 📝 Where did Hitler get the funds to invest in economic development programs such as the autobahn when the German economy was in a depression?
- 📝 Where did Asian Americans go to school during the 'separate but equal' era?
- 📝 Where did the Gaels originate?
- 📝 Where did the “vikings wear helmets with horn” stereotype come from and why?
- 📝 Where did the archived discussions in Google Groups come from?
- 📝 Where did the term "Middle Ages" come from?
- 📝 How did the KPA cross the Han River on 28 June 1950?
- 📝 Where did Roman senators mostly live in the time of Tiberius or Caligula?
- 📝 After the fall of the Roman Empire, where did their armor go? Was it used by any dark ages forces?
- 📝 Where did John Adams write of the night he shared a bed and an argument with Benjamin Franklin? Did Franklin write of it as well?
- 📝 Where and how did the concept of "incorporation" originate?
- 📝 Where did the Roman money involved in the spice and luxury trade end up?
- 📝 Where did the so-called "Japanese Skulls" end up?
- 📝 Where did the Crusaders go after 1291?
- 📝 Where did the French revolutionists get their weapons?
- 📝 Where did the Greeks look for descendants of the Byzantine dynasties?
- 📝 Where did the money come from to build the Colosseum?
- 📝 Where did the design of the US Colonel insignia come from?
- 📝 Where and how did the allies scrounge enough food for the Soviets AND the British?
- 📝 Did the Russian Empire have a claim to Sweden? Was there ever a time where they could have pursued it?
- 📝 Where did tree spiking prevent the most logging?
- 📝 Did Hannibal start the Second Punic War prematurely?
- 📝 Where and how did scientists of the 18th and 19th century learn foreign languages?
- 📝 When and where did Louis Blanc say the famous "from each according to his abilities..."?
- 📝 Where did Metternich say the Balkans began?
- 📝 Where did Vasco Núñez de Balboa first see the South Ocean?
- 📝 Where did the term "Radical Republican" come from?
