How many people in the US starved to death during the Great Depression?
score:28
According to my quick reading of the Life and death during the Great Depression by JosΓ© A. Tapia Granadosa and Ana V. Diez Roux, the only noticeable increase of mortality was suicide, with a noticeable decline of mortality in every other category.
It's interesting that this paper was written in 2009, before the (shall we say) sensationalist Russian claim of 7 million deaths.
According also to Michael Mosley, life expectancy actually rose through the Great Depression. In his Horizon programme Eat, Fast and Live Longer he claims
From 1929 to 1933, in the darkest years of the great depression when people were eating far less, life expectancy increased by 6 years.
Upvote:0
I'm afraid you have to understand that at the time period we are talking about it was especially hard to get independent information and government- backed information is almost guaranteed to be doctored for political, social and other reasons. This would apply not only to the US, but to Germany and the Soviet Union as well. If you remember a phrase from 'Doctor Zhivago' movie: '...this is another disease we don't have in Moscow - starvation...'. It's natural for the governments to deny and hide any information about any adverse events. In addition, it may be easily claimed that no one died of starvation because unless somebody is locked up and deprived ANY food he can easily die of pneumonia, for example, which his body won't be able to handle because it's too weak because of poor nutrition and which otherwise it could handle. In that sense, unless the statistics were properly doctored, it could be very interesting to compare it with the statistics for the previous and later 5-10 years.
Upvote:27
Health researchers collected data on causes of death in 114 U.S. cities during the Great Depression. Their findings confirm the impressions of many observers in the 1930s, mortality did not increase during the Great Depression:
They include a table that shows trends in death rates per 100,000 population. Starvation does not appear on the list, nor does it rate a mention in the article. The researchers do acknowledge that malnutrition led to decreased health during the Depression, but not to increased mortality. Malnutrition was a widespread problem, starvation was not.
A few comments about the table. First, death due to disease generally did not increase during the period, so the researchers are not misclassifying "death due to malnutrition" to "death due to disease." Second, note that in the table they even break out diseases like Smallpox, responsible for death rates under 1 in 100,000. This generally implies that starvation would have been responsible for deaths at an equivalent or lower rate.
This study confirms other studies that find, for example, that the infant mortality rate consistently declined across the 1930s:
The caveat is that this study is based on urban populations, and certain rural populations may have experienced more severe poverty. But the overall message is that deaths due to starvation would have been rare throughout this period. My admittedly very ballpark extrapolation from these data is that we might find a rate in the thousands per year before the New Deal agencies got up and running:
Importantly, this study shows that economic crisis does not guarantee a mortality crisis, but instead reinforces the notion that what crucially matters is how governments respond and whether protective social and public health policies are in place both during and in advance of economic shocks
Sources: David Stuckler, Christopher Meissner, Price Fishback, Sanjay Basu, Martin McKee. 2011. "Banking crises and mortality during the Great Depression: evidence from US urban populations, 1929-1937." Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. (link)
Price Fishback, Michael Haines, and Shawn Kantor. 2005. "Births, Deaths, and New Deal Relief During the Great Depression."
More post
- π Has an army ever not cancel its preplanned attack after a security breach?
- π How widespread was dueling in the United States from its formation to 1860?
- π What is the equivalent in France of the "Victorian era"?
- π Is there historical evidence on what might have been a maximum hair length for males in 1st century Judea?
- π What was considered utility clothing before WW2?
- π Which ancient text claims that everything has been said before?
- π Was Operation Kugelblitz really a success for the partisans?
- π Did Alexander the Great destroy a city to demonstrate his ability to reign?
- π Counterfactual reasoning and analogical reasoning
- π What Land Runs were there in the U.S., and were the Indians paid for their land?
- π Why was there a reference to the Battle of Hastings in Harper Lee's novel?
- π Why did serfdom disappear gradually in England?
- π What is the origin of straight municipal boundary line in NJ?
- π How were the Greek city-states "unified"?
- π What Calendar was used in Carthage?
- π What's the oldest monomyth?
- π A zoo during the rule of Omayyad or Abbasid dynasty?
- π Why does some Califate money feature crosses?
- π Were the Spanish conquistadors really motivated by myths like El Dorado?
- π Why didn't the British test the effects of shells on trench warfare defenses?
- π Why might one think that Australia gained independence from the UK in December 1920?
- π Wales and Ireland in medieval times
- π Were Magellan's wife and kids held hostage?
- π What was the Carthaginian (Punic) term for elephant
- π (Why) are there two different versions of the photograph of inmates at the Buchenwald concentration camp?
- π What campaigns did the Mexican army fight against American Indians in the North?
- π What is the English name for the "ΠΡΠ»Π°ΠΌΡΠΊΠΈΠΉ Π΄ΠΆΠΈΡ Π°Π΄ - ΠΠΆΠ°ΠΌΠ°Π°Ρ ΠΌΠΎΠ΄ΠΆΠ°Ρ Π΅Π΄ΠΎΠ²" organization?
- π Were there any local or regional elections in Nazi Germany?
- π Were heroin addicts used to help Spanish flu patients?
- π How were dagger axes used in battle?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π How many people in the US starved to death during the Great Depression?
- π What is wrong with Russian claim that 7 million people starved to death in the Great Depression in the USA?
- π During the Middle Ages, how many people could be fed by fishing?
- π How many people were beheaded by the Guillotine in France during the French Revolution (1789-1794)?
- π How many people died in the nazi concentration camps and death trains and marches?
- π How many people were executed during the reign of Henry VIII?
- π How many people did the Islamic Caliphate send to the Maghreb during the Arabization of North Africa?
- π How did people deal with ice on the roads during the horse-and-buggy era?
- π During the Great Depression, did the US Army do a study involving paying people to dig a hole and fill it back up?
- π How do Friedman and Bernanke's explanations about the causes of the Great Depression compare?
- π In England, how many Jews died during the persecutions of the crusades during 1190-1200?
- π How many Britons lived in India during the British Raj (1858 - 1947)?
- π How many people were affected by the Holodomor [Famine-Genocide in Ukraine]
- π How did the way commanders ask their troops to deal with the immediate death of their comrades vary by country/culture during WWII?
- π How was ownership of property managed during the Black Death, when so many original owners had died?
- π How many Dutch lived in Indonesia during the colonial era vs native population?
- π How many troops would the White Armies have had at their peak during the Russian Civil War?
- π How much time did people have to take shelter during the Blitz in 1940-41?
- π How many people died in the British Isles from religious persecution between 1532 and 1791?
- π How did China deal with the Black Death during the second plague pandemic?
- π How were expelled ministers "witnessed" during the Great Ejection of 1662?
- π How realistic were von Papen's plans to invade Canada using "German cowboys" during the Great War?
- π How many tons of steel were produced in Russia during the Russian Civil War?
- π Why did Franklin D. Roosevelt confiscate gold from the American people during the Great Depression?
- π How many people lived in the Mexican territories annexed by the US?
- π How many rapes did the Wehrmacht commit in the Soviet Union during World War II?
- π During the Great Depression in America, was there an increase in popularity of Communism?
- π How many ministerial deferments were there during WWII for the United States?
- π In the Great Purge, how many purged military officers served in Tsarist times?
- π How many people were fighting in the North Korean Army in peak strength in the Korean War?