In light of the fact that Donatism is heresy, why do most churches require a priest to bless the elements?
score:5
Once Apostolic succession is rejected, it seems difficult to justify setting requirements for administration. The Protestant view seems to vary from "it doesn't matter who is doing it"1 to "you must have a Master's of Divinity and be ordained"2 to present communion. Ordination is commonly required, or at least recommended.
From what I can tell, this idea comes from the idea that the "minister" has been chosen by God to edify the church, and the people are to go outside the gathering for their ministries. The ordained minister is set apart by/for God to minister to His people so that they can go out into their communities; serving communion is not the responsibility of laypeople.
Ephesians 4:11-13 (ESV)
And he [God] gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until we all attain to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ,
In the United States, the IRS may have something to do with it as well:
Treas. Reg. § 1.107-1(a) also provides examples of specific services considered duties of a minister, including:
1. Performance of sacerdotal functions;
2. Conduct of religious worship;
3. Administration and maintenance of religious organizations and their integral agencies;
4. Performance of teaching and administrative duties at theological seminaries.
Note 1:
The teaching of some Baptists (though not all agree):
Because the Bible indicates that all believers in Christ are priests (1 Peter 2:5; Revelation 5:10), there is no need for a priestly class to administer either baptism or the Lord’s Supper. Although normally the pastor of a church baptizes and presides at the Lord’s Supper, any member designated by the church could do so. In the Lord’s Supper, each believer priest, and not just the one presiding is, to partake of the bread and the cup. (BaptistDistinctives.org)
Note 2:
Article IV, paragraphs 22, 23 of the Constitution of the United Church of Christ:
22 Ordination is the rite whereby the United Church of Christ through an Association, in cooperation with the person and a Local Church of the United Church of Christ, recognizes and authorizes that member whom God has called to ordained ministry, and sets that person apart by prayer and the laying on of hands. By this rite ordained ministerial standing and status as an Ordained Ministerial Partner is conferred and authorization given to perform the duties and exercise the prerogatives of ordained ministry in the United Church of Christ.
23 An Ordained Minister of the United Church of Christ is one of its members who has been called by God and ordained to preach and teach the gospel, to administer the sacraments and rites of the Church, and to exercise pastoral care and leadership.
UCC requirements for ordination as minister:
All ordained ministers must hold bachelor's and Master of Divinity degrees and must meet other professional and religious standards. (Wheat Ridge Congregational Church)
Upvote:4
I read this question a while ago and even though it has a satisfactory answer, I thought that there would be something more accessible in The Lamb's Supper by Dr. Scott Hahn. And I think these tidbits will help.
He says that thoughout the Church (and throughout the ages) there many Eucharistic prays but they all contain the same parts. The Epiclesis (when the priest places his hands over the bread and wine calls down the Holy Spirit) and the The Narrative of Institution (when the bread and wine is transformed into Christ's Body and Blood) are the foremost of these parts.
The priest relates the drama of the Last Supper, when Jesus made provision for the renewal of His covenant sacrifice through all time.
...
When the priest speaks the words of institution-"This is My body ... This is the cup of My blood, the blood of the new and everlasting covenant'-he is not merely narrating, he is speaking in the person of Christ, Who is the principal celebrant of the Mass. By the sacrament of Holy Orders, a man is changed in his very being; as priest, he becomes "another Christ." Jesus ordained the Apostles and their successors to celebrate the Mass when He said: "Do this ... in remembrance of Me" (1 Cor 11:25). Note that Jesus commanded them to "do this" and not "write this" or "read this".
That last sentence summarizes why regular folks can't do it because we'd just be reading the words and they'd have no effect. The understanding of scripture as handed down by the Sacred Traditions of the Catholic Church in the Sacrament of Holy Orders have apparently chosen to interpret the person Jesus is commanding to "Do this" as not me and my wife at dinner, but the people He was actually talking to and those who were appointed by the people He was talking to take their place.
Upvote:5
As a youth leader I celebrated the Lords Supper with my students with no ordained minister present—and all the ministers of my church knew. Baptists can celebrate communion at home with the family. The early church did the same: after the meal, the bread was taken and broken remembering Jesus' sacrifice.
If a pastor is present, we do respect his position and allow him to preside, much like in the Anglican church where a priest defers to a bishop if one is present. I have never heard of a Baptist church which teaches that communion is invalid if a pastor is not present. My church even allowed me to baptize my son.
Baptists believe strongly in the "priesthood of all believers". The temple worship is done away with; our High Priest is Jesus Christ, and all believers are are priests on earth (according to Baptist belief).
I would also point out, that even under the old covenant, no priest was required in order to celebrate the Passover in the home. The High Priest did offer the paschal lamb in the temple; but since Christ, our High Priest and our paschal lamb, has already been sacrificed, no further sacrifice is needed. So Baptists believe the Lords Supper is a memorial meal, not a sacrifice—it is Holy and real, connecting us to Christ and to each other through the Holy Spirit.
Upvote:10
As far as the Roman Catholic Church and the Church of England are concerned, it certainly is Canon Law.
900 §1. The minister who is able to confect the sacrament of the Eucharist in the person of Christ is a validly ordained priest alone.
907 In the eucharistic celebration deacons and lay persons are not permitted to offer prayers, especially the eucharistic prayer, or to perform actions which are proper to the celebrating priest.
B 12 Of the ministry of the Holy Communion
- No person shall consecrate and administer the holy sacrament of the Lord's Supper unless he shall have been ordained priest by episcopal ordination in accordance with the provisions of Canon C 1.
That the Eucharist is not affected by the worthiness of the minister is also enshrined in a number of church documents (Article 26 in the Church of England, for example).
However, an unworthy minister is still a minister. The ontological change wrought by the Spirit at ordination is what makes a man able to effect the sacrament. Whether he is worthy or not is of no consequence. A layman has not undergone that ontological change, and so is unable to celebrate the Eucharist. He can say the words and do all the right actions, but it is simply not effective.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church addresses this:
1141 The celebrating assembly is the community of the baptized who, "by regeneration and the anointing of the Holy Spirit, are consecrated to be a spiritual house and a holy priesthood, that . . . they may offer spiritual sacrifices."9 This "common priesthood" is that of Christ the sole priest, in which all his members participate:10
Mother Church earnestly desires that all the faithful should be led to that full, conscious, and active participation in liturgical celebrations which is demanded by the very nature of the liturgy, and to which the Christian people, "a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a redeemed people," have a right and an obligation by reason of their Baptism.11
1142 But "the members do not all have the same function."12 Certain members are called by God, in and through the Church, to a special service of the community. These servants are chosen and consecrated by the sacrament of Holy Orders, by which the Holy Spirit enables them to act in the person of Christ the head, for the service of all the members of the Church.13 The ordained minister is, as it were, an "icon" of Christ the priest. Since it is in the Eucharist that the sacrament of the Church is made fully visible, it is in his presiding at the Eucharist that the bishop's ministry is most evident, as well as, in communion with him, the ministry of priests and deacons.
9 Lumen Gentium 10; cf. ⇒ 1 Pet 2:4-5.
10 Cf. LG 10; 34; Presbyteriorum ordinis 2.
11 Sacrosanctum Consilium 14; Cf. ⇒ 1 Pet 2:9; ⇒ 2:4-5.
12 ⇒ Rom 12:4.
13 Cf. PO 2; 15.
More post
- 📝 Are there theological explanations for why God allowed ambiguity to exist in Scripture?
- 📝 Did Jesus say that he was coming back within a generation?
- 📝 When did the Orthodox and Catholic Churches distinguish the manner in which the Sign of the Cross was to be made?
- 📝 Are there any biblical examples of Early Church disciples praying to deceased saints in order to request their intercessory prayer?
- 📝 What is the Catholic interpretation of John 12:32?
- 📝 Do all Catholic seminary schools require instruction in Latin and/or Greek?
- 📝 According to Catholicism, what particular truth will the great apostasy deny?
- 📝 Why was Martin Luther attempting to change the canon?
- 📝 Were the Jews right in accusing Jesus of claiming to be God?
- 📝 Prior to Exodus 3:5, was it customary to take off one's shoes on sacred ground?
- 📝 Is there a sound doctrine or biblical explanation why Satan is called "the ape of God"?
- 📝 Did God forgive sins based on Jesus' future sacrifice?
- 📝 Who is the young man mentioned in Mark 14:51?
- 📝 Life of Jesus from the age of 12 to 30?
- 📝 What is the basis for the Catechism saying that one can always be forgiven by perfect contrition come from?
- 📝 Were Luther and Calvin Aphthartodocetists?
- 📝 Did the ante-Nicene Church fathers write in uncials?
- 📝 Why is God on Sarah's side when she asked Abraham to cast out Hagar and Ishmael?
- 📝 What is a non-denominational church?
- 📝 Where did the rule regarding abstaining from Communion after divorce originate?
- 📝 When were "psalms and hymns and spiritual songs" in Colossians 3 first argued to refer only to the Book of Psalms?
- 📝 Is Nessa or Vanessa a Catholic name?
- 📝 Virgin Mary in Old Testament?
- 📝 For how long did the early Christians share all their possessions?
- 📝 Was Constantine The Great a Nicene Christian?
- 📝 What does Catholic Church say about the post-resurrection wound marks of Jesus?
- 📝 Where did St. Catherine of Siena say: “Preach the Truth as if you had a million voices. It is silence that kills the world.”?
- 📝 Is female h*m*sexuality against the Law of Moses?
- 📝 Why is the day before Ash Wednesday sometimes called Pancake Tuesday?
- 📝 Why does the apostle John write far more clearly about the deity of Christ than seems to be the case in the other gospel accounts?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 In light of the fact that Donatism is heresy, why do most churches require a priest to bless the elements?
- 📝 Does the fact that Joseph was a *tekton* require that Jesus was as well?
- 📝 Why do people believe that the 7 kingdom parables and the 7 churches of revelation represent the same things?
- 📝 Why did God hide away the fact that He had the Son in the Old Testament times?
- 📝 Why do most Christians seemingly not mind swearing on the Bible in light of Matthew 5:33-37?
- 📝 Did most of the people that Jesus heal believe he was God? If so, why does the Bible not record them asking for salvation?
- 📝 How do Christians who reject the idea of purgatory deal with the fact that most people don't repent of every sin before they die?
- 📝 Why do most Catholic Churches not say the Nicene Creed anymore and instead say the Apostle's Creed?
- 📝 What is the most dangerous heresy that exists in the church today?
- 📝 Why is it that so many Churches have a problem with Halloween but not with the other pagan holidays?
- 📝 Why don't many churches obey Paul's command that women must be silent in church?
- 📝 According to those holding that Lazarus was literally raised from the dead, why did Matthew, Mark, and Luke not mention it?
- 📝 What is the oldest hymn (with music) that is still sung in churches today?
- 📝 What is the difference between icons and idols in churches that permit icons?
- 📝 Why do most Christians not follow the Talmud?
- 📝 Why did so many early church fathers say that sex was a consequence of the Fall?
- 📝 What did Jonathan Edwards have to say about the fact that he owned slaves?
- 📝 Why would popes choose the name Pelagius in light of the Pelagian heresy?
- 📝 Why does the LDS church believe that alcohol was forbidden, despite being common in the Bible?
- 📝 What was the most likely method of crucifixion that was used on Jesus?
- 📝 Why are the books of the Protestant Bible in the order that they are in?
- 📝 Are there any churches that do not accept the teachings of Paul?
- 📝 Are there Christian groups that speak in tongues but as a policy require translation of the God-given language?
- 📝 Are there any modern churches that subscribe to the Donatist heresy?
- 📝 Why did the people believe that no one would know where the Christ came from?
- 📝 Why did God describe the light as being good, but not the darkness?
- 📝 What's the name of the heresy that declares Mary Mother of God is a goddess?
- 📝 Why did the Western and Eastern churches react to their respective states so differently?
- 📝 Why are the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption of Mary such a big deal that all Catholics must believe in them?
- 📝 Why does the LDS church (Mormon) put so much more emphasis on the family than most other denominations do?
