Under what basis does the Catholic Church consider animals, in particular great apes, not to be persons?
Upvote:0
Under what basis does the Catholic Church consider animals, in particular great apes, not to be persons?
Humans being have the gift of free will given directly by God (CCC 1730), as well as an immortal soul (CCC 1703). Only people have the gift of reason, where animals do not have including great apes.
1730 God created man a rational being, conferring on him the dignity of a person who can initiate and control his own actions. "God willed that man should be 'left in the hand of his own counsel,' so that he might of his own accord seek his Creator and freely attain his full and blessed perfection by cleaving to him.
1703 Endowed with "a spiritual and immortal" soul,5 the human person is "the only creature on earth that God has willed for its own sake." From his conception, he is destined for eternal beatitude.
Language is the proof of intelligence, which even great apes do not possess. They simply have a system of communication, as do most animals, but it is no way based on reason. That distinguishes the human race and animals including great apes, possessing a simple animal soul and not an immortal human soul!
Animals, including great ape, are incapable of adoring God as man can with all his heart, mind and soul!
Upvote:1
Personalism, a concept promoted by St. John Paul the Great was (and memorize this one because it will be on the test)
A person is an entity toward which the only reasonable attitude is love
Now, to me that seems like a description of another human being, not a one of the lower animals. You cannot substitute love with lunch.
The "Gloomy Dean", Dean Inge of St. Paul's in London in the early 20th century would have had the same propositions, that because animals can X, we should grant them Y. And he did this mixing Christianity and science and coming up with astonishing platitudes that sound more like pessimistic Hinduism.
The same writer makes one or two other very curious remarks; one of the most astonishing being the following: "The lower animals were not made for our sake. So much science can affirm without hesitation." We can affirm without hesitation that science cannot affirm anything of the sort. Science (when used to mean the study of hard fact and not a mere modernist mystery and hocus-pocus) refuses absolutely to affirm anything whatever about what animals were made for; or even, within its own logical operation, whether they were made at all
THE RELATION OF MAN TO THE ANIMALS, G.K. Chesterton - May 26, 1928
G.K. Chesterton didn't like torturing animals, he preferred vivisecting politicians and multi-millionaires to rabbits and apes, but he couldn't see animals being merciful to one another. And it would take mercy to have the rights held by humans - because apes wouldn't even be expected to hold those rights within their community.
Now, maybe reading Tarzan leaves me in relation to the great apes the same as as a Protestant who has never read Belloc, but I do not think apes or dolphins or army ants are model citizens and I cannot (because I was not) be made to love them the way I love my wife, my neighbor, my kids or even my enemies.
Upvote:4
Humans have the gift of free will given directly by God [CCC 1730], as well as a soul [CCC 1703]. Only humans have an immortal soul.
Many higher mammals have the traits you speak of: wolves, most domesticated dogs and cats, dolphins and porpoises, and most primates. Sentience is not a function of humanity.
Scripture specifically makes humans special from the time of creation:
Genesis 1:26 And God said, "Let us make man in our image, after our likeness, and they shall rule over the fish of the sea and the fowl of the heaven, and over the animals and over all the earth and over all the creeping things that creep along the earth. 27: And God created man in his image; in his image he created him; man and woman he created them. 28: And God blessed them, and God said, "Be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth and subdue it, and rule over the fish of the sea and the fowl of the sky and over all the beasts that tread upon the earth.
CCC 1704 goes on to say By free will, [man] is capable of directing himself towards his true good.
In these regards, both scripture and Catholic theology recognize the supremacy of humans over all other species on the planet.
I'm not sure if this is a defense, per se, as you have asked, but God was very specific about the supremacy of humans. Of interest, cultures which are not monotheistic have by and large less empathy towards nonhumans than the Church. If anything, Catholic theology supports animal rights and the relief of suffering as long as it is not to the detriment of humans [CCC 2415-2418].
To sum up, sentience, if present, is not a substitute for humanity. (Of note, the CCC specifically prohibits slavery of persons [CCC 2414].) Your argument that "some modern scientists" believe sentience makes a nonhuman a "person" is not a replacement for scripture or dogma.
More post
- 📝 Are there examples of changes or reinterpretation of Catholic or conservative Protestant dogmas?
- 📝 Do Christian groups which think h*m*sexuality is a sin think you can be a practicing h*m*sexual and also a Christian?
- 📝 Where did the trait in man come from which causes him to deny the superiority of God?
- 📝 Should dating couples who put themselves regularly to the occasion of sin be granted absolution if they do not have a will to avoid such situations?
- 📝 Can someone clarify the eastern orthodox teaching "Temps Immobile" of Fr. Alexander Schmemann?
- 📝 How do opponents of Penal Substitution explain God's declaration that He "will not leave the guilty unpunished"?
- 📝 What are Lutheran teachings on salutary effects of communion?
- 📝 Are there any major / orthodox Christian leaders that taught that Paul didn't meet Jesus?
- 📝 Does the Minimal Facts Argument have the potential to the biggest Christian revelation over the last thousand years?
- 📝 Did John Bunyan really dream the Pilgrim's Progress? Had he memorized all the verses?
- 📝 How should Selah be read?
- 📝 Why does only the priest receive Communion under both kinds at a Catholic Mass?
- 📝 What are the classics/giants in Systematic Theology?
- 📝 Is there any evidence of the crucifixion of Jesus outside of the bible?
- 📝 Can a non-Catholic receive Baptism (to formally marry a Catholic), without converting to the Catholic faith?
- 📝 What is the religious significance of Christmas lights?
- 📝 Movies and Music during Lent for Orthodox Christians
- 📝 Jehovah's Witnesses and Shunning Reconciled with New Testament
- 📝 What is the origin and basis for the Catholic teaching regarding Mary's vow of celibacy prior to her betrothal?
- 📝 What is the historical evidence of gagging, retching, dry heaving and vomiting during exorcisms?
- 📝 How are verses referenced?
- 📝 What did the Dominicans have against the immaculate conception?
- 📝 Atheist Arguments
- 📝 How was the Bible used to reduce modern slavery?
- 📝 Are there any followers of Catharism today?
- 📝 Was the snake a wayward animal?
- 📝 How many wives can a Christian have?
- 📝 Identifying Saints in Icon
- 📝 What are scholarly objections to the divine inspiration of the Book of Mormon?
- 📝 Why does Catholicism have priests but Protestantism does not?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Under what basis does the Catholic Church consider animals, in particular great apes, not to be persons?
- 📝 Under what basis does the Catholic Church condemn the use of drugs while permitting alcohol?
- 📝 On what basis does the Catholic Church teach that women cannot be ordained?
- 📝 On what basis does the Catholic Church oppose penalisation of women guilty of abortion?
- 📝 Under what conditions does the Catholic Church explicitly call the laity extraordinary ministers?
- 📝 What does the Catholic church teach about fate of non-Catholic christians?
- 📝 What does the Roman Catholic church teach about those who die having never heard of Christ?
- 📝 What does Catholic Church say about the post-resurrection wound marks of Jesus?
- 📝 Does the Catholic Church consider abortion to be murder?
- 📝 Why does the Roman Catholic Church consider beatification of the pope?
- 📝 What does the Catholic Church mean when it calls humans co-creators with God?
- 📝 Does the Catholic Church teach that it has the authority to change what is morally right and wrong?
- 📝 Does the Roman Catholic church consider HIPAA to be an unjust law?
- 📝 On what basis does Thomas Aquinas say that the Church existed since the time of Abel?
- 📝 What rules does the Catholic Church have for venerating crosses/crucifixes on Good Friday?
- 📝 Does the Catholic Church consider it sinful for couples who aren't able to conceive to have sex?
- 📝 On what grounds does the Catholic church reject sacraments of protestant denominations?
- 📝 What does the Catholic Church say happens on the New Earth?
- 📝 What does the Orthodox church consider to be the defining features of Christian meditation?
- 📝 What doctrinal value does the Catholic Church place on "Cantate Domino"?
- 📝 Does the Catholic church consider Mark 16:9-20 to be biblical canon?
- 📝 Why does the Catholic Church consider protestant baptisms valid sacraments, but not protestant marriages?
- 📝 What does the Catholic Church require for a parent's name to appear on the child's baptism certificate?
- 📝 What does a returning Catholic who contracted marriage in a Protestant church need to do when the spouse wants to remain Protestant?
- 📝 To what degree does the Church of England consider the Genesis creation account to be metaphoric?
- 📝 What does the Roman Catholic Church teach about covenant theology?
- 📝 What does the Catholic church say about its own presence or absence when the tribulation starts?
- 📝 What exactly does the Catholic Church mean by the "Virginity" of Mary?
- 📝 Does the Catholic Church consider not administering a feeding tube passive euthanasia?
- 📝 By what authority does the Catholic church have priests?
