What Food is Rochester, New York Known For?
When I first visited Rochester, New York, I didn't expect the food scene to be such a big part of the experience. You walk the streets, and the aroma of cooking draws you in. With every bite of a local dish, I felt like I was stepping into a larger story deeply rooted in the community. I learned quickly that Rochester has its unique culinary identity that resonates with locals and curious visitors alike.
One of the most iconic dishes you’ll hear about is the "Garbage Plate.” Originating from a local eatery called Nick Tahou Hots in 1918, this dish has become a rite of passage for anyone who comes to Rochester. A Garbage Plate typically consists of a combination of multiple items, like cheeseburgers, hot dogs, macaroni salad, baked beans, and home fries, all piled high on a plate and drenched in hot sauce. It’s chaotic yet satisfying. In a 2018 survey by the Democrat and Chronicle, over 60% of respondents claimed the Garbage Plate was their top food pick that represents Rochester.
As I dove deeper into the culinary fabric of Rochester, I encountered the renowned "Pittsford Wegmans" supermarket, which is like a temple for food lovers. Wegmans, a family-owned supermarket chain, is a source of pride for Rochesterians. They were ranked No. 1 on the 2021 "America’s Favorite Grocery Store" list by Business Insider. What’s fascinating is the way Wegmans showcases regional products. You want local flavor? Try their fresh-baked bread and locally sourced produce that makes everyday meals extraordinary.
But wait, I didn’t just stick to the usual routes. I ventured into the lesser-known dishes, like the famous "White Hots." These are unique to Rochester and refer to a type of hot dog made with pork and beef—no beef blood, just plain meat! They are best served with mustard and onions and are a staple at summer barbecues across the city. According to local lore, White Hots began circulating in the 1920s, reflecting the city's love for straightforward, hearty food.
And what about pizza? The city’s pizza is certainly deserving of mention. Rochester-style pizza is characterized by its unique rectangular shape and thick crust. You will frequently find it served "half pepperoni"—a code for half the pizza topped with pepperoni. One of the most famous spots for this type of pizza is "Salvatore’s Pizzeria," which boasts having made a record of over 1 million pizzas each year as per their internal data. That's quite a lot of pizza!
Let’s not overlook the local bakery scene. I had the fortune of stopping by "Doughnut & Coffee," which is known for its delicious crullers and cream-filled doughnuts. They have a flaky outer texture that crumbles at the first bite, and each one is filled to the brim with rich vanilla custard or marshmallow cream. According to their website, they produce over a thousand doughnuts a day—the proof is right there when you see the line out the door!
Rochester also loves its unique take on sandwiches, especially the famous "Fish Fry," which is a must-try during the Lenten season. Served on a bun with a side of coleslaw, this meal has made waves in various seafood competitions in the state. Many local eateries put their own twist on it, but it usually features a breaded and fried white fish, lightly seasoned. According to a 2020 survey by the Rochester Business Journal, over 70% of Rochester residents indulge in this dish during the season, showcasing its widespread popularity.
In recent years, Rochester has also embraced the craft beer movement. Local breweries offer a ton of options ranging from IPAs to stouts. "Genesee Brewery," founded in 1878, is a staple of Rochester that draws in tons of visitors. Their beers are so popular that they even manage to ship them as far as Texas! Interestingly, the brewery hosts live music events and food trucks, proving that the connection between food and community is alive and well here.
So, the next time you find yourself in Rochester, dive into its culinary offerings. You’ll find that every corner of the city has a story just waiting to be tasted. From the legendary Garbage Plate to the local favorites like White Hots, and even artisanal coffee from the thriving café scene, Rochester's food is more than just a meal. It’s a journey filled with rich history, community pride, and genuine flavor. Who knows? You might discover your new favorite dish along the way.