Was the battle of Stalingrad "unique" in the annals of history?
Upvote:4
You usually don't get casualties that goes so high; one side or the other will have the sense to realise that the battle is lost and retreat. When they can't, their losses will ramp up while the winner's will stay relatively modest.
One battle with very high losses on both sides is the Dano-Swedish Battle of Lund. However, that was not due to the generals grinding the units down; it was a very confused affair where the Swedish cavalry broke of to chase the Danish cavalry, while the Swedish infantry was very hard pressed and would have lost if the cavalry had not returned. In the end, the casualty rates for both armies where over 50 % (including wounded and prisoners of war). It has been noted as one of the bloodiest pitched battles ever.
Upvote:16
Another battle between the Russians and Germans that seems similar is Battle of Tannenberg during WWI. Out of 206,000 men of the trapped Russian Second Army 78,000 were killed or wounded and 92,000 taken prisoner [1]. However it seems Stalingrad still has the edge on this because both sides had their backs against the wall in 1942, whereas Tannenberg was a bit more one-sided.
The Battle of Seden destroyed an entire french army (mostly captured, not dead) and lost the Franco Prussian war for them but like Tannenberg was one sided and over quickly. An eastern example of a high casualty battles which outcome decided a large war is the Battle of Fei River (700,000 out of 870,000 deaths on the losing side according to the Book of Jin). But again this was fairly one sided.
So maybe encirclement isn't the important thing and it's about countries stubbornly pouring manpower into the meat-grinder of an "un-loseable" war of attrition. The Western Front of WWI is a great example (lots of decimated units here[2]). Verdun being a particularly horrific fight over some hilly ground near Verdun-sur-Meuse. Loss at Verdun might have might have lost the war for the Allies, but didn't losw it (not immediately anyway) for Germany. Perhaps Stalingrad was more decisive than Verdun in particular, but if you compare it to the western front in general there are a lot of similarities.
As far as other important battles with horrible casualty rates go the Battle of Antietam and percentagewise more lethal Battle of Stones River are good American examples. Leipzig is a good example before industrialised warfare.
So while there are lots of examples of desperate fighting, encirclement and awful causalities. I would agree that given the intense struggle on both sides and it's decisive role in the Great Patriotic War (that's WW2) Stalingrad was fairly unique, with the western front in WW1 being the strongest contender in my mind.
[1] Source: Sweetman, John (2004), Tannenberg 1914 (1st ed.), London: Cassell, ISBN 978-0-304-35635-5 p158
[2] Somme example: the 1st Newfoundland Regiment suffered 91% casualties in the Somme, 801 men, 500 dead, 233 wounded, which puts it in second place to the 10th Battalion West Yorkshire on the same day but I can't find those numbers
[PS] Thought I would mention ambushes like the The Battle of Salsu (302,300 out of 305,000) or 'Quintilius Varus, give me back my legions!, but I don't think they can be compared to Stalingrad.
More post
- 📝 In segregated South, would Asian-Americans be treated as "colored" or as whites?
- 📝 Westernmost and easternmost locations that Charles V visited in his empire?
- 📝 Why did the United States not invade North Vietnam?
- 📝 What does the first Versal in Book of Kells refer to?
- 📝 Who named the Democratic Party?
- 📝 Was the IMF complicit in destroying the Romanian economy?
- 📝 If the UK received the highest amount of Marshall Aid, why was it broke?
- 📝 Was the French philosopher Pierre Bayle a Calvinist believer or an atheist?
- 📝 What was the earliest known written constitution?
- 📝 Did men and women feast together in early medieval East Francia?
- 📝 Is individual level data from British India censuses (1881 - 1941) available?
- 📝 Did humans hunt with dogs before planting crops for food?
- 📝 Why wasn't there more use of wind power in antiquity?
- 📝 Was Lampsacus a Phocaean or Milesian colony?
- 📝 What role did War elephants play in the battle of Thermopylae?
- 📝 What percent of Sparta's population were citizens in various centuries?
- 📝 When was tofu invented? Was it specifically for vegetarian consumption from the beginning?
- 📝 Looking for quote about workhouses
- 📝 Why was the Irish War of Independence in 1918 successful when other revolts failed?
- 📝 How did the Swedish soldiers pray during the Thirty Years' War?
- 📝 Bow shape of WW1 warships
- 📝 Is there a painting from before the colonization of the Americas depicting travelers from far away visiting European nobles?
- 📝 How did the Nuremberg Trials decide whether a guilty defendant was to be sentence to death or life imprisonment?
- 📝 Did Farmers Survive Communist Famines?
- 📝 When did the trademark symbol come into use?
- 📝 Can anyone help me identify this old coin?
- 📝 What is this stick that William III of England/Orange is holding in this portrait?
- 📝 During the execution of the internment of Japanese during ww2 in the USA, did any other Asian Americans have to prove descent?
- 📝 Why didn't the steppe bow spread further?
- 📝 Were people buried in the 19th century with a cloth around their head if so why?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Was the battle of Stalingrad "unique" in the annals of history?
- 📝 What was the first battle in history fought by vast-majority-% "distance-shooting" non-mechanized force?
- 📝 Which battle was the most lopsided result in terms of casualties?
- 📝 Was the tugboat ever part of a WWII battle group?
- 📝 Was there an assassination attempt against Xerxes in the battle of Thermopylae?
- 📝 How difficult was to escape from a naval battle after engaging into one during the Age of Sail?
- 📝 Was there really a navy officer named Picard at the Battle of Trafalgar?
- 📝 What was the last battle fought mainly by sail-powered ships?
- 📝 What was the first successful mass tank battle of WW1?
- 📝 Why was the last battle of the War of 1812 fought fully half a year after the official end of the war?
- 📝 Was the Battle of Tours really the turning point for the Umayyad expansion into Europe?
- 📝 Who was Richard of York at the Battle of Grunwald?
- 📝 At the Battle of Zama, was the Roman army more "native" than the Carthaginian?
- 📝 How was the dynamics of a naval battle in the 17th century?
- 📝 How was the naval battle of Guadalcanal affected by Japanese ships loading High Explosive shells rather than Armor Piercing?
- 📝 What was the actual cause of the disaster for the Royal Navy’s battlecruisers in the Battle of Jutland?
- 📝 When was the earliest recorded battle with the usage of gunpowder as an offensive weapon?
- 📝 Battle of Xiaoting: was Shu's invasion doomed from the start?
- 📝 What was the significance of the BEF moving into the gap between German forces in First Battle of the Marne?
- 📝 Who was the oldest recorded participant in a battle whom we know of?
- 📝 What was the first instance of native Americans using gunpowder weapons in battle and did they ever make their own powder?
- 📝 What was the role of Nikita Khrushchev during the battle of Stalingrad?
- 📝 Was the Battle of Trafalgar strategically pointless?
- 📝 Was there Western tactical air support during the Battle for Berlin?
- 📝 Where was the Battle of Antioch (613 CE) fought?
- 📝 Why was the battle of Bouvines that incredible?
- 📝 What was the aftermath of a battle in the Middle Ages? How did wounded soldiers proceed?
- 📝 What was the nature of the Japanese cabinet crisis after the Battle of Taierzhuang?
- 📝 Why was there a reference to the Battle of Hastings in Harper Lee's novel?
- 📝 When was the deadliest year in human history in absolute terms?