Did Jeanne d'Arc really tell a woman that she couldn't serve on the battlefield?
score:13
SHORT ANSWER
'Stay in the kitchen', yes (more or less), but this relates to a prophecy made by Catherine de La Rochelle, and had nothing to do with the battlefield.
Joan of Arc said very little about the role of women that we know of. According to accounts from her trial, she spoke mostly about herself, distancing herself not from the battlefield but from doing any killing.
DETAILS
What Joan of Arc / Jeanne d'Arc did was to dismiss the prophecy of Katherine de La Rochelle, a 'prophetess' with the Armagnacs during the Hundred Years War. Records from her trial state Joan recalled meeting Catherine, and that the latter told her that
a certain white lady came to her, arrayed in cloth of gold, telling her to go through the good towns with heralds and trumpets which the king would give her, to proclaim that whosoever possessed gold, silver, or hidden treasure should immediately bring it forth; and that she would immediately know those who having any hidden did not bring it forth, and would be easily able to find it; and it should go to the paying of Jeanne's men-at-arms.
Joan of Arc's response to Catherine was that
she should go back to her husband, and look after her household (in French "son mesnage") and care for her children.
Again according to the trial records, Joan
wrote telling her king what he should do, and when she came to him she said that this question of Catherine was folly and nothing more.
Although one could interpret Joan's actions as aimed at undermining a rival, it seems more likely that she saw Catherine as a charlatan whose prophesy, if followed, would serve no useful purpose. Kelly DeVries, in Joan of Arc: A Military Leader, argues that the evidence points to Joan being someone who
was a devoted believer in the Christian God...[and] had one cause: a unified, unoccupied France.
Despite wearing men's clothes and fighting alongside men, there is no evidence that Joan of Arc had 'feminist views'; she did what she felt had to be done to achieve her goals, and her actions (she said) were driven by the voices she said she heard. Telling Catherine to
go back home and do the housework, etc, is one of Joan of Arc's few recorded statements concerning (in any manner) the subject of "gender roles" - the other chief statement being her comment that "I would prefer to spin wool beside my poor mother [i.e., rather than going to the war], because this is not of my social station", explaining elsewhere that she had resisted for several years her saints' orders to go to the war.
Helen Castor, author of Joan of Arc: A History (in this article) says Joan
would beat camp followers with the flat of her sword and angrily drive them away...unless soldiers came forward to marry them.
This action speaks more of a leader who was devout and who wanted to maintain a disciplined fighting force rather than a feminist or a populist. Susan Crane, in Clothing and Gender Definition: Joan of·Arc sums up her role on the battlefield thus:
She sees herself as a fighter...not a mother or a bride; but the modifications she brings to war leadership by carrying her own standard, refraining from killing, and preferring her stick and her standard to her sword constitute her refusal to succumb uncritically to the conventional model of the masculine warrior.
More post
- 📝 Why did France just give up without a major fight in WW2?
- 📝 Why did Nazi soldiers do Hitler's bidding?
- 📝 How did a travelling Roman army decide where to temporarily camp for the night?
- 📝 Which eras have historians proposed that we are currently living in?
- 📝 Why was Khomeini in France? Who allowed him to leave and why?
- 📝 Did Ramsay Macdonald have a Vietnamese mistress living near Downing Street?
- 📝 Who was responsible for the partition of India?
- 📝 Which was the last war in which swords were used?
- 📝 How do modern historians evaluate Sherman's "Total War"?
- 📝 When did American elections begin to use the ballot?
- 📝 What changes happened in law enforcement and criminal trials during the Nazi era in Germany?
- 📝 Why did the jews leave Israel and spread out through the world?
- 📝 Where can I find the text of "Ecerinis"?
- 📝 Protected Merchant Ships in WWII used for the relocation of Prisoners of War
- 📝 Help identifying Italian uniform, rank, regiment
- 📝 How was money transferred before digital transactions?
- 📝 Changes to the school leaving dates in Scotland and Northern Ireland
- 📝 How Did The US Justice System Lose Sight of Intent?
- 📝 When did COVID-19 hit the international news?
- 📝 Why did post-Roman rulers abandon tax-paid army?
- 📝 How did Maximilien de Robespierre lose control of his Reign of Terror and die by the guillotine?
- 📝 What military uniform is this?
- 📝 How were USSR oblasts and cities governed?
- 📝 Has mercantilism ever been successful?
- 📝 Why did the baths of Bath need a hypocaust?
- 📝 Is there a commonly-accepted book or a site that explains the history-of-everything?
- 📝 Why is Jesus' crucifixion dated to AD 30–33?
- 📝 Perceptions and relationships of 14-15th century Spaniards / Romani / Moors
- 📝 Is there an accurate "World History Timeline" for all geographic areas?
- 📝 Why would a 16th century Italian painter choose canvas over wood panel?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Did Jeanne d'Arc really tell a woman that she couldn't serve on the battlefield?
- 📝 Did JFK really say "Hitler is one of the greatest men…one of the most significant figures that ever lived"?
- 📝 Did the emperor Ashoka really build hospitals or is that a myth?
- 📝 Did Brahms really leave Germany because he was dissatisfied with the political realities of that time?
- 📝 Did Turkey invade Cyprus to keep the USSR out? Is there really CIA files that prove this for real?
- 📝 Did people in the late 1800s and earlier really think that there would be, or already exist, "mechanical men"?
- 📝 Why did Mussolini say that people are not really free if they don't have access to the ocean?
- 📝 Did Nazi propaganda really claim that England imposed the war on Germany?
- 📝 When did people decide that all caps means the writer is shouting?
- 📝 Did Adolf Hitler ever address the fact that his own appearance was almost an exact opposite of what he considered the ideal Aryan appearance?
- 📝 Did Albert Einstein really receive this rejection letter from the University of Bern?
- 📝 When did the Romans finally acknowledge that they were living in an empire?
- 📝 How did the American Civil War help the U.S economy recover from the Panic of 1857 given that civil wars are extremely destructive?
- 📝 Why did the Royal Society in 1771 believe that a continent further south than Australia should exist?
- 📝 Why is it that the maiden name is traditionally dropped when a woman is getting married?
- 📝 Did the Celts really go into battle naked?
- 📝 Did Catherine the Great really call for the abolition of serfdom?
- 📝 Did the US and Soviet navies really come close to blows in the Indian Ocean in 1971?
- 📝 When did the English and Americans realize that vegetables were healthy?
- 📝 Did Truman really believe that Hiroshima was a military base?
- 📝 Why did Stephen Ambrose believe that the election of Aaron Burr would have led to the end of the USA?
- 📝 Did the Tamil People discover that the earth was round 2000 years ago?
- 📝 Did the Americans trade destroyers in the "destroyer deal" that they would later need themselves?
- 📝 Did any ancient polytheistic religion hold that theirs was the only pantheon?
- 📝 Why did the states that were born out of the Louisiana purchase adopt a common law system, and not a civil law system?
- 📝 How did residents of Estonia and Latvia prove that their family settled in the country prior to 1940, in order to become citizens in 1989?
- 📝 How did the "Standard Model" physics theory get that name?
- 📝 Did Hitler really keep the blueprints of the current Nebraska state Capitol building in the drawer of his desk?
- 📝 Did the Spartans really taunt Philip II of Macedon with a single word?
- 📝 Did Wilson's 'He kept us out of war' really win the 1916 Presidential Election?